
On September 26, 1960, an estimated 70 million Americans tuned in to watch history: the first-ever televised presidential debate.
On one side stood John F. Kennedy—young, tan, confident and composed. On the other was Richard Nixon—pale, visibly sweating under the hot studio lights and sporting a five o’clock shadow that television makeup failed to conceal.
While radio listeners thought Nixon won on substance, TV viewers overwhelmingly saw Kennedy as the victor.
The takeaway? Looks mattered. Nixon himself would later admit that his poor appearance on television played a major role in his election loss.
From that moment on, physical appearance became an undeniable factor in presidential politics. As technology advanced, the commander-in-chief went from being just a name on a ballot, a face in black and white on the newspaper page, to a daily presence in American life—on TV, in full color print, and eventually, across social media.
Every wrinkle, every wardrobe choice, every unflattering angle became a talking point.
And in recent years, few presidents have faced as much scrutiny for their appearance as Donald Trump. His comb-over, patchy self-tanner and questionable dye jobs have been the subject of endless memes and late-night monologues.
But what if we’re looking at “hotness” the wrong way? What if true presidential attractiveness isn’t about chiseled jawlines and camera-ready smiles, but about character, leadership and legacy? Maybe it’s time to redefine what makes a president hot.
Since retaking office in 2025, Trump has signed a slew of Executive Orders. How many of these have actually benefited the average American? Instead of critiquing his physical appearance, let’s focus on what really defines a president’s “hotness”: their legacy.
Most rankings of U.S. presidents—C-SPAN’s Presidential Historians Survey, The American Political Science Association or Gallup polls—tend to assess a leader’s effectiveness only during their time in office. That means presidents are often judged by circumstances they inherited rather than those they created. Herbert Hoover took office in an era of robber barons and an unregulated stock market, setting the stage for the 1929 crash. The events that led to the Iranian Revolution—and the hostage crisis that would define Jimmy Carter’s presidency—were rooted in a U.S.-backed coup in 1953. These factors are often overlooked when ranking presidents, but they play a crucial role in understanding their leadership and decisions.
A truly attractive leader wields power for the good of their country during their presidency and even long after their time in the Oval Office—and history proves some did this far better than others.
And so, in the spirit of celebrating leaders who used their power for progress, we present: The Inkspot’s top 5 hottest presidents—ranked not by looks, but by legacy.
Even die-hard Carter supporters would admit that ranking him this high is controversial. By the end of his term, his approval rating had cratered, his economic policies were widely panned and his handling of the Iran hostage crisis led to a humiliating defeat in the 1980 election.
Carter was painted as weak, indecisive and unable to command the respect of foreign leaders. His presidency, to many, was defined by inflation, gas shortages and failed diplomacy.
But that’s only half the story. Carter inherited a volatile global situation largely shaped by Cold War policies long before he took office. The roots of the Iranian Revolution can be traced back to the 1953 CIA-backed coup that overthrew Iran’s elected prime minister—an action taken under Eisenhower’s administration. Similarly, the U.S. economy in the late 1970s was suffering from stagflation, a crisis decades in the making.
Despite these challenges, Carter’s presidency wasn’t all missteps. He brokered the Camp David Accords in 1978, securing peace between Israel and Egypt—a diplomatic achievement that still holds weight today. By brokering one of the most significant diplomatic achievements in Middle Eastern history, Carter demonstrates that conflict-resolution was a strength, not a weakness.
Perhaps Carter’s most attractive trait: He prioritized human rights in foreign policy, taking a stance that would influence later administrations.
Where Carter really solidifies his ranking, though, is in his post-presidency. The man spent decades using his influence for humanitarian work, eradicating disease, advocating for fair election and building homes with Habitat for Humanity well into his 90s.
Unlike many former presidents, he never used his position to enrich himself—he used it to serve. Carter’s legacy proves that true attractiveness isn’t about commanding presence or electoral victories—it’s about the lasting good you do.
The name “Hoover” isn’t exactly synonymous with presidential success. For many, he’s the face of the Great Depression, the guy who failed to stop economic catastrophe and left millions homeless. His belief in small government intervention during a massive financial crisis made him look detached and ineffective, and his refusal to directly assist struggling Americans led to the rise of “Hoovervilles”—shantytowns for the destitute.
But that view ignores Hoover’s extraordinary career as a humanitarian and public servant, both before and after his time in office.
Hoover’s legacy is more complex than his disastrous presidency. He didn’t create the stock market crash—he inherited an unregulated financial system shaped by the greed of the Roaring Twenties. The collapse would have been a challenge for any president, and in fairness, the New Deal policies of Franklin D. Roosevelt—which are often credited with rescuing the economy—didn’t immediately solve the crisis either.
Before the White House, Hoover was one of the most globally respected relief organizers in history. As head of the U.S. Food Administration during World War I, he developed massive supply chains to prevent food shortages, not just for the United States but for millions of civilians and soldiers across war-torn Europe.
His work after the war helped prevent mass starvation in Germany, Poland, Belgium and even Soviet Russia, despite ideological tension. He was so effective at relief efforts that “Hoovering” became a European slang term for getting America to send food.
As Secretary of Commerce, Hoover played a crucial role in modernizing infrastructure, including expanding the commercial aviation industry and standardizing air traffic regulations.
And while his presidency is largely remembered for its failures, Hoover’s commitment to public service continued long after he left office. In the post-World War II years, he worked with President Truman as the Coordinator of Food Supply for World Famine in 1946, playing a key role in preventing starvation in devastated nations. He also advised the U.S. government on occupation policies in Germany and Austria, helping to shape post-war reconstruction efforts.
In 1947, a Republican-led Congress tapped Hoover to lead the Commission on the Organization of the Executive Branch of Government, which became known as the “Hoover Commission.” While Republicans had hoped Hoover would help dismantle FDR’s New Deal programs, he instead recognized the growing complexities of modern government and proposed sweeping reforms that strengthened the Executive Branch. His work led to bureaucratic improvements that modernized the federal government, making it more efficient and adaptable for the postwar era.
Even as his presidency was marred by the Great Depression, his earlier work demonstrated a leader who was willing to serve the world, not just his country. This kind of selfless dedication may not have won Hoover points with magazine editors, but it makes him one of history’s most impactful presidents—and, by this list’s standards, undeniably attractive.
Teddy Roosevelt practically redefined what it means to be a “man of action.” Whether charging up San Juan Hill or exploring the Amazon Basin, Roosevelt embodied vigor and determination. But his true attractiveness lies in his ability to translate that energy into meaningful leadership.
A trailblazer of conservation, Roosevelt was instrumental in establishing 230 million acres of public lands, including 150 national forests, 51 bird reserves and 18 national monuments. Roosevelt founded the U.S. Forest Service, ensuring that America’s natural beauty would be preserved for future generations.
Roosevelt’s diplomatic achievements are equally compelling. His role in negotiating the 1905 Treaty of Portsmouth, which ended the Russo-Japanese War, earned him the Nobel Peace Prize—the first for any American president. His decision to create the Panama Canal demonstrated his vision for global commerce and U.S. influence.
And, of course, there’s the famous “teddy bear” story. Roosevelt’s refusal to shoot a defenseless bear speaks volumes about his sense of fairness and integrity, qualities that are infinitely more attractive than good looks alone.
Sure, Teddy Roosevelt was ruggedly handsome with a dashing mustache—but he was an impactful environmentalist with diplomacy.
Roosevelt’s legacy is complex, he had a strong imperialist streak—one of the first presidents to wield America’s military might aggressively on the world stage. His role in the Spanish-American War and his “Big Stick” diplomacy left a lasting (and controversial) impact on U.S. foreign policy and the U.S’s reach, ending Spain’s claims to Cuba, and gaining sovereignty over Guam and Puerto Rico while annexing Hawaii.
His stance on race was complicated: while he invited Booker T. Washington to the White House—an unprecedented move—his administration also saw the dishonorable discharge of 167 Black soldiers in the Brownsville Affair, despite a lack of solid evidence against them.
Yet, his legacy is still undeniable. He expanded the power of the presidency, transforming it from a passive administrative role into an active force for progress. His Square Deal focused on breaking up monopolies, regulating industries and improving conditions for the working class. He was one of the first presidents to challenge the dominance of corporate America, taking on big businesses to prevent exploitation.
Even after leaving office, Roosevelt remained an influential figure, advocating for progressive policies and global diplomacy until his death. He proved that a president’s impact shouldn’t be judged solely by their years in office, but by their lasting contributions to society.
For decades, Ulysses S. Grant was written off as a mediocre president, overshadowed by corruption scandals and political missteps. Historians often ranked him near the bottom, viewing his administration as a period of ineffective leadership marred by cronyism. But in recent years, Grant’s reputation has undergone a massive reevaluation—and for good reason.
While detractors focus on the corruption within his administration (the Whiskey Ring scandal, the Credit Mobilier scandal), Grant himself was never personally implicated in wrongdoing. In fact, he was known for his moral integrity and deep sense of justice, qualities that made him a uniquely attractive leader.
His greatest legacy? Defending Reconstruction and civil rights in the post-Civil War era. Grant aggressively pursued the Ku Klux Klan, signing the Enforcement Acts, which allowed federal troops to arrest Klan members and dismantle their terror campaigns against newly freed Black Americans. His commitment to civil rights was nearly unprecedented among 19th-century presidents.
As a military leader, Grant was nothing short of legendary. His command of the Union Army led to victory in the Civil War, securing the survival of the United States and ending slavery. His military prowess earned him a reputation as a relentless, strategic thinker who understood the weight of leadership under fire.
Grant’s presidency also reflected his commitment to preservation—not just of the Union but of the country’s natural beauty. In 1872, he signed the Yellowstone National Park Protection Act, establishing the first national park in the world. This act set the precedent for environmental conservation, laying the foundation for Teddy Roosevelt’s work, which remained a cornerstone of American policy well into the 21st century.
Grant’s legacy doesn’t end with his presidency. After leaving office, he embarked on an ambitious world tour, meeting with foreign leaders and reinforcing America’s presence on the global stage. Even in his final years, dying of throat cancer and facing financial ruin, Grant proved his resilience. He wrote his now-famous “Personal Memoirs,” a best-selling account of his military career, ensuring his family’s financial security after his death.
Despite the challenges of his presidency, Grant was a leader who stood by his principles, fought for equality and cemented his place in history as one of the most consequential figures of the 19th century. That level of strength and perseverance? Hot.
Abraham Lincoln is the undisputed No. 1 on this list—not because he was conventionally handsome (he wasn’t) but because his legacy is unmatched. When it comes to defining moral courage, leadership and resilience, Lincoln is the standard.
Of course, Lincoln wasn’t always popular in his time. Critics viewed him as too slow to act on emancipation, and he faced constant political pressure from both abolitionists and conservatives who felt he wasn’t doing enough—or was doing too much. His presidency saw massive dissent, and his policies were deeply controversial. Southern states despised him so much they seceded from the Union immediately upon his election.
But Lincoln didn’t walk into the White House with a blank slate. He inherited a country on the brink of total collapse, a crisis decades in the making. The issue of slavery had been boiling over for generations, exacerbated by a string of ineffective compromises and leaders who failed to take decisive action. His immediate predecessors—James Buchanan, Franklin Pierce and Millard Fillmore—largely tried to appease both sides, allowing tensions to fester.
By the time Lincoln took office in 1861, seven Southern states had already seceded, and the Confederacy had been established before he even stepped foot in the White House.
The situation at Fort Sumter in South Carolina became the first flashpoint of war, as Confederate forces demanded the surrender of the Union garrison. Buchanan, in the final months of his presidency, did nothing to reinforce the fort or address the rising rebellion, leaving Lincoln with an impossible decision: surrender and appear weak, or fight and risk full-scale war. Lincoln chose to stand firm, made the hard choice, and send supplies to the fort, prompting the South to fire the first shots of the Civil War.
While divisive in his time, history has proven Lincoln right. His leadership during the Civil War preserved the Union, and his Emancipation Proclamation and push for the 13th Amendment ended the legalized enslavement of millions. His ability to navigate one of the most divisive, violent periods in U.S. history speaks to his brilliance as both a strategist and a moral leader.
Lincoln’s speeches remain some of the most powerful and enduring pieces of American rhetoric. The Gettysburg Address, though just 272 words, redefined the purpose of the war and reaffirmed the ideals of democracy. His Second Inaugural Address, delivered as the Civil War drew to a close, emphasized reconciliation and unity, rather than vengeance—an approach that would be tragically cut short by his assassination.
Even after death, Lincoln’s influence only grew. He became a symbol of American perseverance, equality and justice. His face is on the penny and the $5 bill. He’s carved into Mount Rushmore. His memorial in Washington, D.C., remains one of the most visited monuments in the country.
Lincoln’s attractiveness isn’t just rooted in his achievements—it’s in his character. Known for his honesty, humility and compassion, Lincoln was a president who truly cared for the people he served.
Even in his personal life, Lincoln’s humor and wit made him deeply relatable. Stories of his self-deprecating jokes and love for storytelling reveal a man who never let his position inflate his ego.
When it comes to attractiveness, no one can top Honest Abe. Forget the stovepipe hat—his legacy alone makes him the hottest president in history.
History has made one thing clear: the best presidents don’t just hold power—they wield it responsibly. They don’t just inherit a crisis; they rise to meet it. And they don’t waste their influence shifting blame or politicizing tragedy—they use it to unite, heal and improve the nation.
Each of the leaders on this list understood that the presidency is more than a platform for self-promotion—it’s a position of service. Serving the American people, the country and the world.
They faced moments of national crisis not by pointing fingers, but by shouldering the burden. When the country was starving, divided, broken or on the brink of war, they didn’t retreat into deflection and divisiveness—they took action, often at great personal and political cost.
And true attractiveness isn’t just about how a president looks behind a podium, but what they stand for when it matters most. The hottest presidents weren’t the ones with the best TV presence, the most photogenic smile (Obama) or the best jawline (JFK). They were the ones who understood that leadership is about making decisions that serve the American people, even long after their time in office.
When a nation looks to its leaders in its darkest hours, real presidents see a moment for service. And that’s the kind of hotness history will remember.
IF YOU SHARE THE INKSPOT'S PASSION for empowering Normal Community's aspiring journalists and equipping them with viable and valuable digital media skills, please consider contributing to our cause.
Your support plays a vital role in enabling the Inkspot to invest in top-tier equipment, maintain memberships in distinguished professional organizations such as the Journalism Education Association and National Scholastic Press Association, send our students to compete at state and national contests, and attend the National High School Journalism Convention.
Your generosity is the key to providing these students with a truly enriching educational experience. THANK YOU.